Record live ray comparison without claiming a performance improvement

This commit is contained in:
Ludovic Marie
2026-10-04 03:52:13 +02:00
parent 349724b3b6
commit 01a7e8b588
2 changed files with 86 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,71 @@
{
"schema": 1,
"minecraft": "26.3",
"entity_culling": "1.11.2",
"original_mod_sha256": "7351b417fc83460def5947636444413874ee812e949342f091ef03674e0c0e58",
"platform": "Linux x86_64",
"graphics": "llvmpipe software OpenGL",
"settings": {
"heap_bytes": 3221225472,
"gc": "G1",
"compact_headers": true,
"render_distance": 12,
"simulation_distance": 12,
"lod_radius_chunks": 128,
"lod_quality": "MEDIUM/MEDIUM/BLOCK",
"terrain_workers": 2,
"runtime_ratio": 0.5,
"world_difficulty": "PEACEFUL",
"empty_culling_whitelist": false
},
"results": [
{
"profile": "m2-balanced",
"ray_enabled": false,
"elapsed_seconds": 120.02619604,
"frame_samples": 599,
"tick_samples": 2400,
"excluded_frames": 0,
"dropped_samples": 0,
"visual_settings_changed": [],
"culling_allocation_counter": {
"thread_id": 49,
"thread": "CullThread",
"counter_observations": 2,
"observed_seconds": 64.509265987,
"observed_allocated_bytes": 1817768,
"observed_bytes_per_second": 28178.40153949851
}
},
{
"profile": "culling-rays",
"ray_enabled": true,
"elapsed_seconds": 120.099980458,
"frame_samples": 584,
"tick_samples": 2401,
"excluded_frames": 0,
"dropped_samples": 0,
"visual_settings_changed": [],
"culling_allocation_counter": {
"thread_id": 49,
"thread": "CullThread",
"counter_observations": 2,
"observed_seconds": 64.321034235,
"observed_allocated_bytes": 1798336,
"observed_bytes_per_second": 27958.754416629756
}
}
],
"notes": [
"Fixed-order single pair using separate copies of the same private saved world and stationary view, with approximately three-minute warm-up before clean frame recordings.",
"One earlier candidate frame capture contained pause exclusions and was discarded; its separate preceding allocation recording had already completed.",
"Allocation counters have their own roughly 64-second observation spans; recordings started approximately 36-42 seconds after joining. Profiling overhead and JIT/cache effects are not eliminated.",
"Both worlds saved and exited with no crash report or remaining game process. The outer foreground control launcher returned 143; it did not expose the game exit status.",
"No useful allocation reduction or whole-game speedup is established. Not a Mac, retained-memory or GPU performance benchmark."
],
"provenance": {
"source_commit": "349724b3b612351daa1616daa79beca8897839ab",
"runtime_mod_matches_linux_ci": true,
"workflow_run": "https://github.com/ludovic111/minecraft-optimization-lab/actions/runs/37168818519"
}
}
+15
View File
@@ -47,6 +47,21 @@ include source and workflow provenance. This is not a whole-game FPS/RAM or Mac
GPU benchmark; repeated real hardware comparisons and live allocation profiles
are required.
A fixed-order live Linux software-rendering pair observed about 28.18 KB/s
allocated by `CullThread` with the hook off and 27.96 KB/s with it on, over
roughly 64-second counter spans. This does not establish a useful reduction.
Allocation samples were dominated by whitelist iteration; the recorded stacks
did not include either ray constructor. The separate `culling-empty` experiment
addresses that observed path. The clean 120-second frame captures produced
599 control and 584 candidate frames, with zero exclusions and matching CSV
counts; captured graphics and worker settings matched except the ray flag.
Both worlds saved and exited without crash reports or remaining game processes.
The outer control launcher returned 143 without exposing the game exit status;
that return is not counted as a verified normal game exit. Selected
[live observations](../benchmarks/culling-rays-2026-10-04/live-observations.json)
retain the recording limits. These are per-thread diagnostic observations, not
retained memory, a statistical comparison, or a Mac result.
The factory hook follows the upstream [Mixin constructor redirect contract](https://github.com/SpongePowered/Mixin/blob/master/src/main/java/org/spongepowered/asm/mixin/injection/Redirect.java).
Compilation uses a checksum-verified publisher JAR; the release mod contains only
original Horizon classes. Profiles without Entity Culling must still load.