Trees of neighbouring chunks overlap on chunk corners, and the one
decorated first wins. With several worker threads vanilla decorates in a
different order each run: seed -2080727421395798566 spawned at Y 64, 66
or 72 over 10 runs. The harness retried vanilla up to 3 times and passed
if any run matched, which still failed when none of them gave 72.
With -Dmax.bg.threads=1 (Util.maxAllowedExecutorThreads) vanilla
decorates in its scheduler's order, the one Horizon follows: that seed
gave 72 in 10 of 10 runs, as Horizon does. The other seeds that varied
are fixed too (10 of 10 each: -8171837717659076940 at 0 67 0,
-5296387317982839690 at -16 73 16, -211473008665507967 at 0 66 112).
The retries go, and vanilla's one spawn is compared exactly.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
lab.VERSION, lab.GAME (.local/minecraft/<version>) and lab.RESOURCES
(.local/horizon-client/<version>) come from the lock, and lab.version_info()
reads the pinned client jar's version.json. Every harness, generator and
tool that named 26.3 (resource folders, jar and source paths, result
records, the vanilla client's --version and asset index, the bare login
client's protocol, the benchmark's options.txt data version, the packet id
table's header) uses them, so a candidate worktree pinned to another version
runs them unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Horizon searched its own spiral of 48-block steps from 0 0 for a dry,
non-leaf top block, so seed 1891623539983467248 spawned at -48 -48 where
vanilla puts the world spawn at 144 71 144 (the player then lands within
the respawn radius, 152 145 in the report).
Vanilla (MinecraftServer.setInitialSpawn): NoiseBasedChunkGenerator.
getOrigin runs NoiseSpawnFinder over the noise settings' spawn_target
points (SpawnTargetPoint.sampleFitness, a 2048/512 then 512/32 radial
search biased towards 0 0); an 11 by 11 chunk spiral around that chunk
takes the first column PlayerSpawnFinder.getSpawnPosInChunk accepts
(getLevelRespawnPos: MOTION_BLOCKING, WORLD_SURFACE and OCEAN_FLOOR
heights, no liquid, a full-topped collision shape); without one, the
origin chunk's centre at the spawn height. The first player is then
placed by PlayerSpawnFinder.findSpawn: the respawn-radius square in a
random coprime order, a free player box with liquids colliding, else the
spawn with fixupSpawnHeight; adventure mode uses the spawn as is.
horizon-world gains worldgen::spawn_finder and OverworldGenerator::origin;
the client's world_spawn module and game/initial_spawn.rs follow
setInitialSpawn and PlayerSpawnFinder, for single player and the
dedicated server alike. Flat worlds use FlatLevelSource's origin and
spawn height.
tools/test_world_spawn_parity.py compares, for the report's seed, the
chunk harness's seeds and 50 random ones, the origins
(VanillaWorldSpawnOracle against the spawn_origin example) and the
level.dat spawn of worlds created by the vanilla dedicated server and by
Horizon's. Vanilla is not deterministic on chunk corners where trees of
neighbouring chunks overlap (decoration order follows its worker
threads), so a mismatching seed reruns vanilla up to three times.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>