Files
airdef/docs/measurements/issue-120-grid.csv
T
chexit 46d2274c8d Measure the #120 balance grid across batteries, ranges and target classes
Wider same-seed sampling of the finite-burn/coast change: baseline 2689d93
(pre-#120) against the current tree, 6 variants x 8 seeds of a 46-drone raid
(batt10/20/50, near200, far1500, hills20). Harness-only: Result carries the
tally's fuse/expired/orphaned/energy_lost counts and a new ignored
sim::balance::issue_120_grid test; no simulation parameters changed.

Findings: kills are equal or up and leaks equal or down in every variant;
fuse misses drop (far1500 70 -> 38 over 8 seeds); hills terrain losses fall
(scrubbed 6 -> 2). MotorEnergyLost never fires in the 48 scenarios and
expired stays <= 1: coast ends before drag reaches the 25% guidance
threshold. Leaks stay concentrated in the ballistic/fast classes
(Iskander/Kinzhal/Kh22/Zircon). No confirmed defect, so no tuning.

Full airdef-core suite: 193 + 8 passed, 0 failed (baseline side 169 + 4).

Co-Authored-By: Kimi Code <noreply@moonshot.cn>
2026-11-04 21:03:01 +03:00

12 KiB

1variantcommitseedsamsdistsentkillsleakedmissilesheavyticksblockedscrubbedcrashesfuse_missexpiredorphanedenergy_lostleaks_by_kind
2batt102689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce11050046351161978100090210Geran3:3;Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:2
3batt10e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e41105004637962981200041230Geran3:2;Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
4batt102689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce21050046406621087500070160Shahed:1;Kh101:2;Kalibr:2;Iskander:1
5batt10e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e421050046415651188300060200Shahed:1;Kh101:2;Kalibr:1;Iskander:1
6batt102689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce3105004639756674000040180Kalibr:2;Zircon:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:1
7batt10e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e43105004639756674000040180Kalibr:2;Zircon:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:1
8batt102689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce41050046388759919000130240Geran3:1;Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:2
9batt10e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e441050046341157885400040200Geran3:2;Kh101:3;Kalibr:2;Kh22:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
10batt102689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce510500463411668871000120260Geran3:1;Kh101:2;Kh22:2;Zircon:1;Iskander:4;Kinzhal:2
11batt10e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e45105004639767691400070260Kh101:2;Kh22:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:1
12batt102689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce610500463610721198600060300Geran3:1;Kh101:3;Kalibr:3;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
13batt10e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e4610500463610731197700070300Geran3:1;Kh101:3;Kalibr:3;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
14batt102689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce71050046351162680200060230Geran3:1;Kh101:2;Kalibr:2;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
15batt10e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e471050046351163680200070230Geran3:1;Kh101:2;Kalibr:2;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
16batt102689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce8105004640662897900060200Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
17batt10e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e48105004640661897900030210Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
18batt202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce120500464157213580000110220Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
19batt20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e4120500464247513578000101220Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
20batt202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce220500464068114629000100360Kh101:2;Kalibr:1;Zircon:1;Kinzhal:2
21batt20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e422050046415711561200040260Kh101:2;Kalibr:1;Kinzhal:2
22batt202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce32050046424641351300090170Zircon:1;Iskander:3
23batt20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e432050046442681354100060230Zircon:1;Iskander:1
24batt202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce420500464248115581000140280Kh22:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
25batt20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e442050046424761561400080270Kh22:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
26batt202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce52050046424711573000070230Kh101:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
27batt20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e452050046424731574800060250Kh101:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
28batt202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce62050046415771469600070290Kalibr:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:2
29batt20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e462050046415801368100050340Kalibr:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:2
30batt202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce72050046406681361900060230Kh101:2;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Kinzhal:2
31batt20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e472050046406681361900060230Kh101:2;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Kinzhal:2
32batt202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce820500464337015632000100230Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
33batt20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e482050046424671466900080230Kh101:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
34batt502689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce15050046451843039400090310Kh22:1
35batt50e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e415050046451832841800070320Kh22:1
36batt502689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce250500464608326575000100310
37batt50e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e425050046460822851400060350
38batt502689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce350500464608127499000100350
39batt50e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e435050046460772752300030350
40batt502689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce450500464518431581000140260Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
41batt50e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e445050046460823160700070320
42batt502689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce55050046442823258600080360Zircon:1;Kinzhal:1
43batt50e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e4550500464608729707000100400
44batt502689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce65050046451822662900090290Kinzhal:1
45batt50e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e4650500464609429584000110390
46batt502689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce750500464159129573000170340Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
47batt50e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e475050046424823152300040370Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Kinzhal:1
48batt502689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce85050046451742667700060300Kinzhal:1
49batt50e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e485050046460752669500040330
50near2002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce12020046415751635000020320Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
51near200e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e412020046415751635000020320Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
52near2002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce22020046405691438300150250Shahed:1;Kh101:2;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:2
53near200e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e422020046405711440100140290Kh101:2;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
54near2002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce32020046396611437500130260Shahed:1;Kh101:2;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
55near200e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e432020046396601234400120220Shahed:1;Kh101:2;Iskander:3
56near2002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce420200464068315459000150300Geran3:1;Kh22:2;Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
57near200e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e442020046406731349500070260Geran3:1;Kh22:2;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
58near2002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce520200463797616406000140330Kh101:1;Kh22:2;Zircon:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:2
59near200e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e452020046415711745500020340Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
60near2002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce62020046397711345000040290Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
61near200e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e462020046397711345000040290Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
62near2002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce72020046397771444800090310Kh101:2;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
63near200e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e4720200464068414465000110330Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:2
64near2002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce820200463887014524000100280Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:2
65near200e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e482020046388671556300040310Kh101:2;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
66far15002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce1201500464247515218100090270Kh101:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:2
67far1500e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e41201500464426814221800040240Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
68far15002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce2201500464157217234200080230Kh101:1;Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
69far1500e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e42201500464337020234200070200Kh101:1;Kalibr:1;Iskander:1
70far15002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce3201500464336819238500080190Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
71far1500e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e43201500464427020236300050210Iskander:2
72far15002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce42015004641573162388000140220Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
73far1500e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e44201500464246816238700050250Kh101:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
74far15002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce52015004642475182550000120240Kh101:2;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
75far1500e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e45201500464246919263500050230Kh101:2;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
76far15002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce62015004636107518257500030370Kh101:2;Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:2
77far1500e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e46201500463887618257500020360Kh101:2;Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
78far15002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce72015004642478202361000100270Kh101:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:2
79far1500e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e47201500464337318236100060250Kh101:1;Kalibr:1;Kinzhal:1
80far15002689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce8201500464156619254400060230Kh101:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
81far1500e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e48201500464246820254400040260Kh101:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
82hills202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce120500464157914606000120270Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:2
83hills20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e412050046406731255100080250Geran3:1;Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:1
84hills202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce22050046388771565180020300Kh101:2;Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:1
85hills20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e422050046388811468170030330Kh101:2;Kalibr:1;Kh22:1;Iskander:3;Kinzhal:1
86hills202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce320500464417912640011100280Kh101:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:1
87hills20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e432050046441781367500170290Kh101:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:1
88hills202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce420500464068215492330130250Kh22:1;Iskander:4;Kinzhal:1
89hills20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e442050046424771551532080240Kh22:1;Iskander:3
90hills202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce52050046397691851401080230Kh22:1;Iskander:4;Kinzhal:2
91hills20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e452050046424651546910040220Kh22:1;Iskander:2;Kinzhal:1
92hills202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce62050046433681361200030220Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
93hills20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e462050046433681361200030220Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
94hills202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce72050046415661355400060190Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:2
95hills20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e472050046433641554600050160Kh22:1;Zircon:1;Iskander:1;Kinzhal:1
96hills202689d933e790b7d751dfcf2a4c6a325e041562ce820500464247714712300140200Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2
97hills20e6a70004406b34ea17884875ce236a5fb4b849e4820500464247714712300130200Iskander:2;Kinzhal:2